I Really Should Read This 26: Hellboy in Hell, Omnibus vol. 4, by Mike Mignola

Hellboy in Hell, Omnibus vol. 4, by Mike Mignola

2018

Sometimes I just want to review a comic, and sometimes I have a hot take: Hellboy in Hell is the closest I've seen a mainstream comic come to applying Chris Ware's techniques.

Up front, yeah, I know the Dave Aja issue of Hawkeye where he copied Chris Ware, but that was a straight single issue homage, not an omnibus collection.

There are six Hellboy omnibuses, the first four of which make up the main saga, and two more which have odds and ends. I ended up starting with book three and have read this one, book four, which acts as a conclusion. 

I liked it but I don't think I'll be buying more of these books at full price. Or maybe I will for ones that Mignola draws himself. I've been spending a lot and need to think about my purchases. The thing is, I bought the original Hellboy Seeds of Destruction issues in the 90s and dropped off them because the story wasn't what I wanted, and here too, the story was beside the point. That said, twenty years had passed between when Mignola drew that story and when he drew Hellboy in Hell, and it seems like he's gotten better. I don't know. I loved his work from the start when I saw it in Rocket Raccoon and his work across Marvel on odds and ends. And I bought Gotham by Gaslight off the stands. But I haven't sat down with his work and given it much thought in twenty years. So maybe the stuff I'm going to talk about here is applicable to his old work. But the work here seems to come from an artist who's been doing the daily practice of art for decades, and is working from his mind rather than a concrete script.

And the book is all the better for it. This is definitely a case of it not what happens that makes it good, but how it's told.

The lower left and upper right panels bleed off the page, the lower left one showing something tucked away in the town, the upper right showing the sky just outside the town. The girl in the window, the family portrait, and the corpse and snake act like mini-sequences within

The story is: Hellboy has died and he's gone to Hell. Hell in this case is conceived as different layers of existence, ending with a city ruled by demons on a lake of fire. Something like that. He throws out lots of mythology, and I got the gist of it, but it was the least interesting part of the book. Hellboy disrupts this by being the one to rule Hell and lead... Anyway, Hellboy has no interest in it. In another book, I'd hate this all with a passion, but as Mignola tells it, it's a kind of gothic prog-rock poetry.

The feeling I was left with at the end was of the musicality of it all. While there is distinct storytelling going on, pages are interspersed with images to create ambiance and rhythm. Mignola uses a technique where pages are drawn on a grid, with no diagonal panels that I noticed, and usually one "framing" panel that bleeds off the page. Within the page, he often uses blocks of panels of one theme, like mini sequences within the larger sequence of the page.

The cat growing in size from panel to panel is a hard thing to convey

These sequences are accented by Dave Stewart's color (who I was praising only days ago for his Daredevil work). I get why Mignola's name is the one on the cover, but Stewart kind of should have been on there too. Flashbacks are used throughout and Stewart's color in these sequences help create a rhythm.

Ten panels on the page, five of them silent

As I finished the main story, I was a little surprised. The "climax" happened in captions and a few images, rather than bloated sequences. Then the story tapered into a denouement of Hellboy on an overcast beach and entering a house. It all felt pretty abstract for an action book. It had a feeling of musicality. 

The second and third panels without a gutter to signify a flashback was a neat little technique

Mignola has some notes at the end of the book where he states he had more issues planned, but as he was coming to the end, he felt it was ready to be wrapped up. And I could see that for the sake of the story, he could have shown more of the end of Hell, but I got what he meant. Hellboy had experienced and learned what he was going to in the story, and the stuff he yadda-yadda'ed over was to resolve a story, but not necessarily going to make it more satisfying to see in action.

A four-page sequence mid-story is done in a watercolor style, and reads like the eye of the (quiet) storm

With Chris Ware, I read interviews with him decades ago where he stated two things: that comics had rhythm and that he let his pages go where they naturally seemed to go. His work can be criticized as boring, and if you're looking for a standard plot with a resolution in his books, you will likely be bored. His pages are about the rhythm and the experience. I think that's where Mignola has gone with his storytelling. He has made a lot of space in his comics to give the atmosphere its own panels. While a lot of panels give story progress, a lot of them don't. A lot of pages would tell the content of the story with multiple panels removed. 

In this sequence, the top left panel on right page has no story-driven reason to exist

Of course the content of the story is important to, to give the reader something to grasp, but having so many superfluous panels creates a more spacious atmosphere, and makes the comic more than merely a story delivery system. It gives you the space to really enjoy the comic form itself.

I really liked this, and my curiosity is to see if this is what Mignola was already doing 20 years ago, like in the Jungle Adventure or Seeds of Destruction. He may well have and I was not that clued into the nuance of how stories were told back when I first read them. I have to imagine that he was somewhat more conventional in his storytelling. With those original Hellboy, he didn't trust himself enough to script them by himself, and he was building up confidence as a writer. With Hellboy in Hell, he had the confidence to substantially change his plan mid-story because of what felt right. He went with the rhythm of the story.

I Really Should Read This 7: Hellboy Omnibus 3, by Mike Mignola and Duncan Fegredo

Hellboy Omnibus 3, by Mike Mignola and Duncan Fegredo

2017, reprinting work from around 2005 to 2010

I used to be a huge Mignola fan... until Hellboy. His work at Marvel and DC stuck out so much, and around 1990, I would buy comics if I saw he drew them. It was usually just the odd issue, but I liked the style so much. I was a reader of John Byrne's Next Men when Hellboy first appeared, and I was into it... Then I read Seeds of Destruction and dropped it in the middle of the second series. I can't go back in time to 1995 and see what I was thinking, but I imagine it was two things: 

1. Image Comics had killed my appetite for art-based comics. I had been so on board with Image and felt so ripped off and embarrassed for reading them that I was aggressively avoiding books with "no story".

2. I was around 20, had just moved to the city, and a lot of books just didn't feel worth my time as a young adult (I've been doing a read of a number of late '90s books that I missed out on at the time).

In a comics forum, I was told, "No, Hellboy is good!" a few times, so I decided to jump in, skipping the first two omnibuses and hopefully getting on when the story was in gear.

Mignola on the cover, Fegredo on the inside

Right up front, the verdict: It's solid. This collects three story arcs (Darkness Calls, The Wild Hunt, and The Storm and the Fury), though according to Wikipedia, the third of these are two separate ones. 

It's sometimes hard to start reading a book that has been praised a lot, because you're expecting it to be awesome from page one. With this collection, Darkness Calls is definitely the least of the three. The first few issues, I couldn't even understand what was going on. There are a lot of characters that look similar (grizzled is a common adjective I'd use for the cast) and a lot of portentous speech. Hellboy walks through a door that's a portal to old Russia and has to get back for three issues while fighting an undying bad guy.  Once it was set up, I could follow what was happening, but the mechanics of getting it going didn't make much sense to me.

Lots of pages like this, sometimes small bad guys, sometimes big, always monochromatic

Anyway, by the end of the first arc, I was on top of enough things to follow the second arc. It was full of portentous talk and a lot of similar characters too, but the main villain was very clear and I could follow the broad strokes, and that carried over to the final arc as well.

I certainly enjoyed this more than the series I read in the mid-90s. The story at that time (that I haven't read in 25 years, mind you) was more of a monster of the week with references to something bigger. This actually was getting to the meat of Hellboy's story and his destiny.

One of the interesting things about this book and character was that Hellboy is both a passive and active hero. He's being thrust into situations and told over and over again what he was born to be, but he also makes his own decisions and actively wrests control of his so-called destiny. That's a pretty cool character arc and not something you commonly see in a protagonist.

These two characters stood out a lot. The pig is probably the most interesting character in the book, just an angry, frustrated thing

The weak part for me is that there are a lot of characters that are there to spout exposition, and you just can't know who they are or distinguish them easily. Lots of withered witches, and I can't tell if they're good witches or bad witches or what. It's just a page of exposition. The colors are nice, but only Hellboy, Nimue (the big bad), and the red haired girl (who pops up in the second arc and is suddenly important) get standout color schemes. Everyone else is a shade of brown or gray. After a while, you just roll with it, and enjoy what is good, but it's not great design.

The art is excellent. I know Fegredo's work, but I hadn't seen any of it in a long time. It's bold and he has a real flow to his storytelling. I found it interesting just how dark images could get and still be understandable. Some pages are almost black. It's an interesting choice.

So, I ordered omnibus four. I doubt I'll feel the need to go back to one and two to read the entirety of the epic, but I enjoyed this collection, and read it about three issues at a time. That's a brisk, solid read.

One thing I want to mention is that this was such a good price. Over 500 pages on a beautiful heavy stock for about $25. In comparison, Marvel's Epic Collections are about 400 pages on cheap, thin paper for $40. Marvel made their money on their comics when they were printed and don't pay royalties on much of it (to my knowledge), while Hellboy is creator-owned, so Mignola and hopefully Fegredo are making money off these collections.  Marvel is printing cheap, selling high, and Dark Horse is printing expensive and selling low. It makes me think about what a fat company Marvel is. They definitely have higher overheads, but I can't help but think that buying a Marvel Epic Collection puts gas in the tank of an executive's Lexus, while buying a Hellboy omnibus simply puts dinner on the table for Dark Horse staff. I have no actual numbers to back that up, I just think the difference in price and print quality is ridiculous, especially considering Marvel's advantage of scale. Dark Horse should probably add $5 to the price and put it in the bank.